← All skills

science-rebuttal-playbook

100 / 100 · Low risk

Fine to try.

By yzlin286-wq/Deepscient (GitHub) · research · 973 stars · scanned at commit 088b022

Use immediately after receiving reviewer reports, when a revision decision says major revision, or when you disagree with a reviewer; covers the numbered-response structure, how to split fixable from arguable points, why unprincipled compliance backfires, and how to escalate a genuine disagreement to the editor.

Works with any agent that supports SKILL.md skills.

What this skill can do

We found nothing in the files we read that matches our rules. That does not prove the skill is safe: see the limits of static scanning.

Install

Paste this into your terminal. It downloads exactly the version we scanned, not whatever is newest.

if [ -e ~/.agents/skills/'science-rebuttal-playbook' ] || [ -L ~/.agents/skills/'science-rebuttal-playbook' ]; then echo 'A skill folder named science-rebuttal-playbook already exists — not replacing it' >&2; false; else d=$(mktemp -d) && git clone --quiet --filter=blob:none --no-checkout 'https://github.com/yzlin286-wq/Deepscient' "$d" && git -C "$d" checkout --quiet '088b0228df4fbb613d00d70823a325677f4970c2' -- 'dsh-science/skills/science/science-rebuttal-playbook' && mkdir -p ~/.agents/skills && cp -R "$d"/'dsh-science/skills/science/science-rebuttal-playbook' ~/.agents/skills/'science-rebuttal-playbook' && rm -rf "$d"; fi

Codex reads ~/.agents/skills directly. For Claude Code, Cursor, Copilot, Gemini CLI, Antigravity or OpenCode, also link it. For Claude Code: ln -s ~/.agents/skills/'science-rebuttal-playbook' ~/.claude/skills/'science-rebuttal-playbook' (other agents: ~/.cursor/skills, ~/.copilot/skills, ~/.gemini/skills, ~/.gemini/config/skills, ~/.config/opencode/skills). Or install through the finder skill, which does both.

Badge for your README

The badge for yzlin286-wq/Deepscient shows the score of its lowest-scoring skill.

[![SkillTrust](https://zalavijaysinh.github.io/skilltrust/badges/yzlin286-wq/Deepscient.svg)](https://zalavijaysinh.github.io/skilltrust/repos/yzlin286-wq/Deepscient/)

Score history