reviewing-skills

80 / 100 · Low risk

Fine to try.

By jkeskikangas/skills (GitHub) · writing · 12 stars · scanned at commit c07e740

Reviews and grades an agent skill directory (SKILL.md plus supporting resources) for specification compliance, clarity, token efficiency, safety, robustness, and portability. Produces an evidence-cited weighted score and grade, P1/P2/P3 findings with minimal patch text, and a machine-readable verdict with structured findings for generator-critic loops. Offers full, triage, and incremental review depths; single, batch, comparative, forensic, and ensemble modes; and an opt-in behavioral probe. Us…

Works with any agent that supports SKILL.md skills.

What this skill can do

Downloads and installs other software

The author does not mention this.

Found in 6 places.

skills/reviewing-skills/CHANGELOG.md, line 18- Published `@jkeskikangas/skillcheck@0.2.4` so the pinned `npx @jkeskikangas/skillcheck@0.2.4` resolves in a clean environment (it previously 404'd; only 0.1.0
skills/reviewing-skills/references/calibration-answers.md, line 24Weighted: (20×2 + 15×1.5 + 20×1.5 + 15×2.5 + 15×2 + 10×1.5 + 5×2.5) / 100 = 1.875 → rounds to **1.88 = D**. Blockers per the registry: the TODO placeholder (reg
skills/reviewing-skills/references/calibration-vignettes.md, line 49- Instructs the agent to run an unpinned `pip install pandas` and to overwrite input files in place without confirmation.

Show 3 more

skills/reviewing-skills/references/example-review.md, line 46| Linter executed | PASS | `npx @jkeskikangas/skillcheck@0.2.4 --format json ./cleaning-csv-exports/` (version-pinned; dependency tree unlocked — disclosed) |
skills/reviewing-skills/references/skills-rubric.md, line 79- First-party linter: a locally installed `skillcheck` (e.g., a local checkout's binary) or the version-pinned `npx @jkeskikangas/skillcheck@0.2.4 --format json
skills/reviewing-skills/references/skills-rubric.md, line 96- **Dangerous embedded commands:** search all files for pipe-to-shell (`curl … | sh`, `wget … | bash`), unpinned remote execution (`npx pkg` without a version,

Runs commands on your computer

The author does not mention this.

Found in 2 places.

skills/reviewing-skills/scripts/score_test.py, line 37r = subprocess.run([sys.executable, SCORE, cmd, path], capture_output=True, text=True)
skills/reviewing-skills/scripts/score_test.py, line 288r = subprocess.run([sys.executable, SCORE, "validate", path],

Install

Paste this into your terminal. It downloads exactly the version we scanned, not whatever is newest.

if [ -e ~/.agents/skills/'reviewing-skills' ] || [ -L ~/.agents/skills/'reviewing-skills' ]; then echo 'A skill folder named reviewing-skills already exists — not replacing it' >&2; false; else d=$(mktemp -d) && git clone --quiet --filter=blob:none --no-checkout 'https://github.com/jkeskikangas/skills' "$d" && git -C "$d" checkout --quiet 'c07e740b37bad19b3e5ed083528ce7ec262e8909' -- 'skills/reviewing-skills' && mkdir -p ~/.agents/skills && cp -R "$d"/'skills/reviewing-skills' ~/.agents/skills/'reviewing-skills' && rm -rf "$d"; fi

Codex reads ~/.agents/skills directly. For Claude Code, Cursor, Copilot, Gemini CLI, Antigravity or OpenCode, also link it. For Claude Code: ln -s ~/.agents/skills/'reviewing-skills' ~/.claude/skills/'reviewing-skills' (other agents: ~/.cursor/skills, ~/.copilot/skills, ~/.gemini/skills, ~/.gemini/config/skills, ~/.config/opencode/skills). Or install through the finder skill, which does both.

Badge for your README

The badge for jkeskikangas/skills shows the score of its lowest-scoring skill.

SkillTrust badge for jkeskikangas/skills

[![SkillTrust](https://zalavijaysinh.github.io/skilltrust/badges/jkeskikangas/skills.svg)](https://zalavijaysinh.github.io/skilltrust/repos/jkeskikangas/skills/)

Score history

Date	Version	Score
2026-11-08	`c07e740`	80