← All skills

critique

80 / 100 · Low risk

Fine to try.

By corca-ai/charness (GitHub) · design · 11 stars · scanned at commit abdb77f

Use when a non-trivial design decision, code change, release, rename, deletion, spec, or workflow change needs a before-the-fact critique, or when reported review findings need approval-oriented evidence disposition. Probe distinct failure angles, then run a counterweight pass that separates real blockers from over-worry before the change locks in.

Works with any agent that supports SKILL.md skills.

What this skill can do

Install

Paste this into your terminal. It downloads exactly the version we scanned, not whatever is newest.

if [ -e ~/.agents/skills/'critique' ] || [ -L ~/.agents/skills/'critique' ]; then echo 'A skill folder named critique already exists — not replacing it' >&2; false; else d=$(mktemp -d) && git clone --quiet --filter=blob:none --no-checkout 'https://github.com/corca-ai/charness' "$d" && git -C "$d" checkout --quiet 'abdb77fd876eb7700c9550b0c6fcd96ee10bee84' -- 'skills/public/critique' && mkdir -p ~/.agents/skills && cp -R "$d"/'skills/public/critique' ~/.agents/skills/'critique' && rm -rf "$d"; fi

Codex reads ~/.agents/skills directly. For Claude Code, Cursor, Copilot, Gemini CLI, Antigravity or OpenCode, also link it. For Claude Code: ln -s ~/.agents/skills/'critique' ~/.claude/skills/'critique' (other agents: ~/.cursor/skills, ~/.copilot/skills, ~/.gemini/skills, ~/.gemini/config/skills, ~/.config/opencode/skills). Or install through the finder skill, which does both.

Badge for your README

The badge for corca-ai/charness shows the score of its lowest-scoring skill.

[![SkillTrust](https://zalavijaysinh.github.io/skilltrust/badges/corca-ai/charness.svg)](https://zalavijaysinh.github.io/skilltrust/repos/corca-ai/charness/)

Score history